My colleague, Gene Dietz Director of Public Works for the City of Eden Prairie has a lot of wisdom to bestow. Gene is a very smart guy and has been around here for a long time. Gene has a lot of sayings that cut right to the chase when summing up various situations. One of those that he expressed to me he got from an article about a conference in Sacramento, California where the condition of levees was being discussed. “In Dutch there is a saying, No policy without a calamity,” cautions Sybe Schaap, a Dutch senator and president of the Dutch Association of Water Boards. Sybe was commenting on levees in California. Gene and the Dutch Senator, Schaap have it all right when it comes to that line of thought. In my fire service career I have made note of the fact that a big share of the Fire Code in the United States is built upon the aftermath of one fatal fire after another.
One such event took place on December 1, 1958 in Chicago. A Catholic School called Our Lady of Angels suffered a fire that took the lives of 92 children and three nuns. There have been other tragic school fires in the United States, but this one received so much press that it became etched into the minds of millions of people. There were many factors that played into the tragic events of that day, but one of the key factors was that this older school building was “grandfathered in” when it came to the requirement of having a fire sprinkler system and proper exiting in place. After this fire all schools were required to install these features regardless of when the building was constructed. If you’d like to find out more about this tragic fire I would suggest reading the book “Sleeping with Angels” or you can go to one of many websites devoted to the topic. A warning though, the photos, descriptions and stories are very heart wrenching and graphic.
My point here is that often Building Inspectors and Fire Inspectors are roundly criticized for code enforcement issues, like installing fire sprinkler systems, but the fact is that those systems are mandated by law only after a tragic event or series of events, just like Gene Dietz and Sybe Schaap will tell you. Or for an non fire related example one needs to look no further back that the 35W Bridge collapse in Minneapolis this past summer. No doubt there will be new regulations in place as a result of the findings from the numerous investigations into that event.
In my world I’d like to see more proactive code development and acceptance so we can avoid the calamity part of the equation.







